Ensemble modelling of carbon fluxes in grasslands and croplands

Sándor, Renáta; Ehrhardt, Fiona; Grace, Peter; Recous, Sylvie; Smith, Pete; Snow, Val; Soussana, Jean-François; Basso, Bruno; Bhatia, Arti; Brilli, Lorenzo; Doltra, Jordi; Dorich, Christopher D.; Doro, Luca; Fitton, Nuala; Grant, Brian; Harrison, Matthew Tom; Kirschbaum, Miko U.F.; Klumpp, Katja; Laville, Patricia; Léonard, Joel; Martin, Raphaël; Massad, Raia-Silvia; Moore, Andrew; Myrgiotis, Vasileios; Pattey, Elizabeth; Rolinski, Susanne; Sharp, Joanna; Skiba, Ute ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8659-6092; Smith, Ward; Wu, Lianhai; Zhang, Qing; Bellocchi, Gianni. 2020 Ensemble modelling of carbon fluxes in grasslands and croplands. Field Crops Research, 252, 107791. 16, pp. 10.1016/j.fcr.2020.107791

Before downloading, please read NORA policies.

	Text Carbon_paper_Uncertainty_evaluation_2019_07_05_without-figures_FCR_mod_.docx Restricted to NORA staff only Download (131kB)
	Image Fig_1.tif Restricted to NORA staff only Download (510kB)
	Image Fig_2.tif Restricted to NORA staff only Download (364kB)
	Image Fig_3.tif Restricted to NORA staff only Download (361kB)
	Image Fig_4.tif Restricted to NORA staff only Download (630kB)
	Image Fig_5.tif Restricted to NORA staff only Download (552kB)
	Image Fig_6.tif Restricted to NORA staff only Download (549kB)
	Text Supplementary_Sándor_et_al.docx Restricted to NORA staff only Download (3MB)
	Text Author statement.docx Restricted to NORA staff only Download (14kB)

Official URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.fcr.2020.107791

Abstract/Summary

Croplands and grasslands are agricultural systems that contribute to land–atmosphere exchanges of carbon (C). We evaluated and compared gross primary production (GPP), ecosystem respiration (RECO), net ecosystem exchange (NEE) of CO2, and two derived outputs - C use efficiency (CUE=-NEE/GPP) and C emission intensity (IntC= -NEE/Offtake [grazed or harvested biomass]). The outputs came from 23 models (11 crop-specific, eight grassland-specific, and four models covering both systems) at three cropping sites over several rotations with spring and winter cereals, soybean and rapeseed in Canada, France and India, and two temperate permanent grasslands in France and the United Kingdom. The models were run independently over multi-year simulation periods in five stages (S), either blind with no calibration and initialization data (S1), using historical management and climate for initialization (S2), calibrated against plant data (S3), plant and soil data together (S4), or with the addition of C and N fluxes (S5). Here, we provide a framework to address methodological uncertainties and contextualize results. Most of the models overestimated or underestimated the C fluxes observed during the growing seasons (or the whole years for grasslands), with substantial differences between models. For each simulated variable, changes in the multi-model median (MMM) from S1 to S5 was used as a descriptor of the ensemble performance. Overall, the greatest improvements (MMM approaching the mean of observations) were achieved at S3 or higher calibration stages. For instance, grassland GPP MMM was equal to 1632 g C m−2 yr-1 (S5) while the observed mean was equal to 1763 m-2 yr-1 (average for two sites). Nash-Sutcliffe modelling efficiency coefficients indicated that MMM outperformed individual models in 92.3 % of cases. Our study suggests a cautious use of large-scale, multi-model ensembles to estimate C fluxes in agricultural sites if some site-specific plant and soil observations are available for model calibration. The further development of crop/grassland ensemble modelling will hinge upon the interpretation of results in light of the way models represent the processes underlying C fluxes in complex agricultural systems (grassland and crop rotations including fallow periods).

Item Type:	Publication - Article
Digital Object Identifier (DOI):	10.1016/j.fcr.2020.107791
UKCEH and CEH Sections/Science Areas:	Atmospheric Chemistry and Effects (Science Area 2017-)
ISSN:	0378-4290
Additional Keywords:	C fluxes, croplands, grasslands, multi-model ensemble, multi-model median (MMM)
NORA Subject Terms:	Ecology and Environment
Date made live:	27 May 2020 08:25 +0 (UTC)
URI:	https://nora.nerc.ac.uk/id/eprint/527821

Item Type:

Publication - Article

Digital Object Identifier (DOI):

10.1016/j.fcr.2020.107791

UKCEH and CEH Sections/Science Areas:

Atmospheric Chemistry and Effects (Science Area 2017-)

ISSN:

0378-4290

Additional Keywords:

C fluxes, croplands, grasslands, multi-model ensemble, multi-model median (MMM)

NORA Subject Terms:

Ecology and Environment