Issues of diffuse pollution model complexity arising from performance benchmarking

Hutchins, M. G.; Dilks, C.; Davies, H. N.; Deflandre-Vlandas, A.. 2007 Issues of diffuse pollution model complexity arising from performance benchmarking. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences, 11 (1). 647-662.

Before downloading, please read NORA policies.

Download (2MB)


Flow and nitrate dynamics were simulated in two catchments, the River Aire in northern England and the River Ythan in north-east Scotland. In the case of the Aire, a diffuse pollution model was coupled with a river quality model (CASCADE-QUESTOR); in the study of the Ythan, an integrated model (SWAT) was used. In each study, model performance was evaluated for differing levels of spatial representation in input data sets (rainfall, soils and land use). In respect of nitrate concentrations, the performance of the models was compared with that of a regression model based on proportions of land cover. The overall objective was to assess the merits of spatially distributed input data sets. In both catchments, specific measures of quantitative performance showed that models using the most detailed available input data contributed, at best, only a marginal improvement over simpler implementations. Hence, the level of complexity used in input data sets has to be determined, not only on multiple criteria of quantitative performance but also on qualitative assessments, reflecting the specific context of the model application and the current and likely future needs of end-users.

Item Type: Publication - Article
Programmes: CEH Programmes pre-2009 publications > Water
CEH Sections: Boorman (to September 2014)
Harding (to July 2011)
ISSN: 1027-5606
Additional Keywords: flow, nitrate, catchment, benchmark, model, CASCADE, QUESTOR, SWAT, Aire, Ythan
NORA Subject Terms: Ecology and Environment
Date made live: 21 Jan 2008 14:25

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item

Document Downloads

More statistics for this item...